The state of California, under the leadership of Governor Gavin Newsom, has made a questionable move to enforce what they label as ‘media literacy’ in K-12 education through Bill No. 873. Set to launch in January 2024, this bill, driven by Democrat Assemblymember Marc Berman, is seemingly aimed at shielding youth from so-called misinformation online. Critics, however, see this as an alarming overstep that could potentially stifle free thought and impose a singular, state-approved narrative on impressionable students.
Pay attention: NY AND California Dems just made "media literacy" a priority for all public schools. This is not organic. The reason for this has nothing to do with the media. This is what they did in Cuba. Communists took over the schools, then they used the trust paradigm in… https://t.co/hs8XWyiLw7
— Robby Starbuck (@robbystarbuck) November 26, 2023
Assemblymember Berman has pushed for the bill as a necessity, citing the threat of online misinformation, referencing divisive topics such as climate debates and vaccine discussions. This law, while presented as a shield against global misinformation threats, could in fact weave a dangerous precedent into the very fabric of education, potentially indoctrinating students rather than teaching them to think critically and independently.
This legislative measure has rightly been met with staunch opposition from conservative groups and individuals who argue it paves the way for state-sanctioned indoctrination and suppresses diverse perspectives.
Echoing California’s steps, New York Governor Kathy Hochul has put forth her own version of media literacy efforts, with a concerning focus on policing speech, and is investing heavily in training that could further the agenda of monitoring and controlling discourse. Such initiatives, while cloaked in the guise of protection against hate speech, raise significant concerns about overreach and censorship.
The trend of states like California and New York taking such measures reveals a troubling inclination to prioritize a curated viewpoint over the time-honored American values of free speech and robust debate. As these states venture down this path, the line between safeguarding against misinformation and propagating a single-minded worldview becomes dangerously thin.